Fire Island holiday rentals

Holiday Rentals in Fire Island

901 available vacation rental offers

2 1
  • tripcom
  • tripadvisor
  • klook
  • booking
  • agoda
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • hotelscombined
  • airbnb
  • eztravel
  • makemytrip
  • rakutentravel
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Fire Island holiday rentals: compare the best deals

Peaceful Relaxation In A Quiet Neighborhood In The Heart Of Long Island - Fire Island
9.9Excellent 305 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$1490/nighttotal: HK$2980 (2 )

Peaceful Relaxation In A Quiet Neighborhood In The Heart Of Long Island

island
East Patchogue
About Peaceful Relaxation In A Quiet Neighborhood In The Heart Of Long Island

About: Island for up to 4 people with an excellent rating of 99% based on 305 reviews. You will be in East Patchogue.

Facilities and services include a garden, a coffee place and a barbecue. Take advantage of the Free Parking with this accommodation in East Patchogue!

Amazing Fully Furnished Near Fire Island Ferries - Fire Island
9.8Excellent 286 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$1558/nighttotal: HK$3116 (2 )

Amazing Fully Furnished Near Fire Island Ferries

apartment
Bay Shore
About Amazing Fully Furnished Near Fire Island Ferries

About: Vacation rental listing for 4 people with an excellent rating of 98% based on 286 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Bay Shore.

Facilities and services: a fridge, a kitchen and air conditioning. Take advantage of the garden in this apartment!

South Shore Beauty In The Woods - Fire Island
9.6Excellent 288 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$1113/nighttotal: HK$2226 (2 )

South Shore Beauty In The Woods

Islip
About South Shore Beauty In The Woods

About:

In-law Apt A Block Away From Patchogue Bay - Fire Island
9.8Excellent 363 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$1332/nighttotal: HK$2664 (2 )

In-law Apt A Block Away From Patchogue Bay

Patchogue
About In-law Apt A Block Away From Patchogue Bay

About:

Cozy Studio - Fire Island
9.8Excellent 219 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$956/nighttotal: HK$4780 (5 )

Cozy Studio

studio
Holbrook
About Cozy Studio

About: Apartment rental for up to 2 guests with an excellent rating of 98% based on 219 reviews. This accommodation is based in Holbrook.

Services and facilities: a coffee place, a fridge and air conditioning. Enjoy free parking with this accommodation in Holbrook!

10 Cayuga - Fire Island
8.5Very good 81 reviews
Fire Island
2 4
HK$9942/nighttotal: HK$19884 (2 )

10 Cayuga

house
Fire Island
About 10 Cayuga

About: Vacation house for 8 people with an excellent rating of 85% based on 81 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.

Services and facilities: air conditioning, a terrace and a kitchen. Take advantage of the garden in this house!

Beachy Condo In The Heart Of Ocean Bay Park With Gas Grill - Dogs Welcome - Fire Island
8.9Very good 90 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$6315/nighttotal: HK$12630 (2 )

Beachy Condo In The Heart Of Ocean Bay Park With Gas Grill - Dogs Welcome

apartment
Fire Island
About Beachy Condo In The Heart Of Ocean Bay Park With Gas Grill - Dogs Welcome

About: Accommodation with an excellent rating of 89% based on 90 reviews. You will be based in Fire Island.

Services and facilities: a terrace, a fridge and a garden. Take advantage of the Free Parking with this accommodation in Fire Island!

Fire Island Pines: Studio Cabin - Fire Island
9.9Excellent 62 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$3654/nighttotal: HK$18270 (5 )

Fire Island Pines: Studio Cabin

studio
Fire Island
About Fire Island Pines: Studio Cabin

About: Vacation rental for up to 2 people with an excellent rating of 99% based on 62 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: a dish washer and a fridge. This apartment in Fire Island also has air conditioning!

Studio Apt In Cherry Grove, Fi. - Fire Island
9.9Excellent 31 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$4546/nighttotal: HK$9092 (2 )

Studio Apt In Cherry Grove, Fi.

apartment
Fire Island
About Studio Apt In Cherry Grove, Fi.

About: Accommodation for up to 4 people with an excellent rating of 99% based on 31 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.

Facilities and services include a barbecue, air conditioning and a freeze. This apartment also has a garden!

Private Queen Bedrm, Events, Petpally, School, Work, Nurses - Fire Island
9.7Excellent 305 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$1140/nighttotal: HK$5700 (5 )

Private Queen Bedrm, Events, Petpally, School, Work, Nurses

apartment
North Bay Shore
About Private Queen Bedrm, Events, Petpally, School, Work, Nurses

About: Apartment to rent for 2 guests with an excellent rating of 97% based on 305 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in North Bay Shore.

Services and facilities: a barbecue, a freeze and a dish washer. This apartment in North Bay Shore also has air conditioning!

3 Bedroom Cottage Rental - Fire Island
9.5Excellent 274 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$2074/nighttotal: HK$4148 (2 )

3 Bedroom Cottage Rental

apartment
Shirley
About 3 Bedroom Cottage Rental

About: Apartment to rent for up to 4 guests with an excellent rating of 95% based on 274 reviews. You will stay in Shirley.

Services and facilities include a coffee place, an iron and a barbecue.

Family Beach House – 1 Block From Beach! - Fire Island
9.3Excellent 33 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$7577/nighttotal: HK$37885 (5 )

Family Beach House – 1 Block From Beach!

apartment
Fire Island
About Family Beach House – 1 Block From Beach!

About: Apartment listing for 6 guests with an excellent rating of 93% based on 33 reviews. You will be based in Fire Island.

Services and facilities include a coffee place, a kitchen and a barbecue. This apartment in Fire Island also has a garden!

Best Fire Island holiday rentals with a pool

Among the 901 accommodations in Fire Island, here are the 8 best rentals with a pool

Sayville Area-exquisite Beachhouse, Stunning, Picturesque, Huge Hot Tub, Private - Fire Island
10Excellent 66 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$6097/nighttotal: HK$12194 (2 )

Sayville Area-exquisite Beachhouse, Stunning, Picturesque, Huge Hot Tub, Private

apartment
Bayport
About Sayville Area-exquisite Beachhouse, Stunning, Picturesque, Huge Hot Tub, Private

About: Apartment rental from $5370 for up to 8 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 66 reviews. You will be located in Bayport.

Services and facilities include a washing machine, a sauna and a jacuzzi. This apartment in Bayport has a swimming pool!

Brushwood House By Smith Point Beach - Fire Island
9.3Excellent 18 reviews
Fire Island
2 4
HK$59231/nighttotal: HK$296155 (5 )

Brushwood House By Smith Point Beach

cottage
Mastic Beach
About Brushwood House By Smith Point Beach

About: Cottage for up to 9 people with an excellent rating of 93% based on 18 reviews. You will stay in Mastic Beach.

Services and facilities include a kitchen, a swimming pool and a fridge. This accommodation also has air conditioning!

Gorgeous Waterfront House W/ View Of Bay - Fire Island
10Excellent 45 reviews
Fire Island
2 5
HK$9093/nighttotal: HK$45465 (5 )

Gorgeous Waterfront House W/ View Of Bay

apartment
East Patchogue
About Gorgeous Waterfront House W/ View Of Bay

About: Accommodation for up to 6 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 45 reviews. You will be located in East Patchogue.

Facilities and services include a garden, a swimming pool and free parking. You can bring your favorite pets this apartment!

Sea La Vie - Fire Island
8.2Very good 28 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$8073/nighttotal: HK$16146 (2 )

Sea La Vie

house
Fire Island
About Sea La Vie

About: Accommodation for 12 guests with a good rating of 82% based on 28 reviews. This accommodation is located in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: a jacuzzi, a fridge and a dish washer. This house is ideal for families.

Joyful Beach House, Viewing The Great South Bay - Fire Island
9.9Excellent 51 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$2678/nighttotal: HK$13390 (5 )

Joyful Beach House, Viewing The Great South Bay

apartment
Patchogue
About Joyful Beach House, Viewing The Great South Bay

About: Vacation rental listing for up to 4 guests with an excellent rating of 99% based on 51 reviews. You will be in Patchogue.

Services and facilities: a freeze, a barbecue and a swimming pool.

Cedar & Glass Home In The Pines - Fire Island
10Excellent 2 reviews
Fire Island
2 2
HK$7577/nighttotal: HK$37885 (5 )

Cedar & Glass Home In The Pines

apartment
Fire Island
About Cedar & Glass Home In The Pines

About: Book this vacation rental for up to 5 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 2 reviews. You will stay in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: a garden, a kitchen and a fitness center. Take advantage of the air conditioning in this apartment!

Dreams Of Paradise Luxury Home With Pool! - Fire Island
10Excellent 5 reviews
Fire Island
2 4
HK$11177/nighttotal: HK$55885 (5 )

Dreams Of Paradise Luxury Home With Pool!

house
Lake Grove
About Dreams Of Paradise Luxury Home With Pool!

About: Vacation rental listing for 10 people with an excellent rating of 100% based on 5 reviews. This accommodation is based in Lake Grove.

Services and facilities: a fridge, an iron and air conditioning. Enjoy free parking with this accommodation in Lake Grove!

Erie Street Retreat - Fire Island
Fire Island
2 1
HK$22232/nighttotal: HK$44464 (2 )

Erie Street Retreat

house
Fire Island
About Erie Street Retreat

About: Vacation house rental. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.

Services and facilities: a kitchen, a dish washer and a fridge. Enjoy a swimming pool in this house in Fire Island!

Best family friendly Fire Island holiday rentals

Among the 901 accommodations in Fire Island, here are the 8 best family friendly rentals

Bellport/e. Patchogue, 4 Bed, 3 Bath, Waterfront. - Fire Island
9.6Excellent 96 reviews
Fire Island
2 4
HK$8992/nighttotal: HK$44960 (5 )

Bellport/e. Patchogue, 4 Bed, 3 Bath, Waterfront.

apartment
East Patchogue
About Bellport/e. Patchogue, 4 Bed, 3 Bath, Waterfront.

About: Apartment listing for up to 6 people with an excellent rating of 96% based on 96 reviews. You will stay in East Patchogue.

Services and facilities: a washing machine, a kitchen and an iron. This apartment is ideal for families.

Gorgeous New East End Cottage Along Water! Minutes From Hamptons And Wineries! - Fire Island
10Excellent 59 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$5855/nighttotal: HK$11710 (2 )

Gorgeous New East End Cottage Along Water! Minutes From Hamptons And Wineries!

cottage
Center Moriches
About Gorgeous New East End Cottage Along Water! Minutes From Hamptons And Wineries!

About: Accommodation from 1986 dollars per night for 6 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 59 reviews. This accommodation is located in Center Moriches.

Services and facilities: a garden, air conditioning and a swimming pool. Take advantage of the Free Parking with this accommodation in Center Moriches!

Charming Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island
9.8Excellent 9 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$6367/nighttotal: HK$31835 (5 )

Charming Fire Island Retreat

island
Ocean Beach
About Charming Fire Island Retreat

About: Island listing from $2777 per night for up to 8 guests with an excellent rating of 98% based on 9 reviews. You will be in Ocean Beach.

Services and facilities: a dish washer, a washing machine and a kitchen. Take advantage of the garden in this accommodation in Ocean Beach.

Sandy Toes - Fire Island
9.9Excellent 27 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$8309/nighttotal: HK$41545 (5 )

Sandy Toes

bungalow
Ocean Beach
About Sandy Toes

About: Bungalow listing for 6 guests with an excellent rating of 99% based on 27 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Ocean Beach.

Facilities and services include a fridge, a garden and air conditioning. This is a pet-friendly accommodation!

Fair Harbor.cooler@the Beach.septmidwks -The Best - Fire Island
8.6Very good 20 reviews
Fire Island
2 4
HK$6062/nighttotal: HK$30310 (5 )

Fair Harbor.cooler@the Beach.septmidwks -The Best

apartment
Fire Island
About Fair Harbor.cooler@the Beach.septmidwks -The Best

About: Vacation rental listing for up to 6 guests with an excellent rating of 86% based on 20 reviews. Your accommodation will be located in Fire Island.

Facilities and services include a kitchen, a dish washer and a barbecue. This is a pet-friendly accommodation!

Charming House In Bellport Village. - Fire Island
10Excellent 2 reviews
Fire Island
2 2
HK$4329/nighttotal: HK$21645 (5 )

Charming House In Bellport Village.

house
Bellport
About Charming House In Bellport Village.

About: Vacation rental listing with an excellent rating of 100% based on 2 reviews. This accommodation is based in Bellport.

Facilities and services include a dish washer, air conditioning and a kitchen.

Seashore Condo Hotel, Obp Room 10, Queen Bed - Fire Island
10Excellent 39 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$3123/nighttotal: HK$15615 (5 )

Seashore Condo Hotel, Obp Room 10, Queen Bed

apartment
Fire Island
About Seashore Condo Hotel, Obp Room 10, Queen Bed

About: Apartment rental for up to 2 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 39 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.

Services and facilities include a barbecue, a coffee place and a garden.

Beautiful 3 Br Full House W/ King Bed On Dead End- 5 Min From Town! - Fire Island
9.9Excellent 123 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$3664/nighttotal: HK$7328 (2 )

Beautiful 3 Br Full House W/ King Bed On Dead End- 5 Min From Town!

house
North Patchogue
About Beautiful 3 Br Full House W/ King Bed On Dead End- 5 Min From Town!

About: Vacation house rental for 7 guests with an excellent rating of 99% based on 123 reviews. You will stay in North Patchogue.

Services and facilities: a freeze, air conditioning and a kitchen. This house in North Patchogue also has a terrace!

Frequently asked questions for the vacation rentals in Fire Island

Destinations nearby

Best pet friendly Fire Island holiday rentals

Among the 901 accommodations in Fire Island, here are the 7 best pet friendly rentals

Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island
9.4Excellent 54 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$4615/nighttotal: HK$23075 (5 )

Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay

house
Mastic Beach
About Waterfront Home With Large Deck And Dock On Narrow Bay

About: House to rent for up to 6 guests with an excellent rating of 94% based on 54 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Mastic Beach.

Facilities and services: a kitchen, an iron and free parking. Take advantage of the garden in this house!

Waterfront & Private Beach Scandinavian Style House Near Bellport, Ny - Fire Island
9.4Excellent 90 reviews
Fire Island
2 3
HK$6424/nighttotal: HK$32120 (5 )

Waterfront & Private Beach Scandinavian Style House Near Bellport, Ny

house
Brookhaven
About Waterfront & Private Beach Scandinavian Style House Near Bellport, Ny

About: House to rent with an excellent rating of 94% based on 90 reviews. You will be based in Brookhaven.

Services and facilities: a dish washer, air conditioning and a barbecue. This house in Brookhaven also has a terrace!

Fire Island Pines Modern Studio W/full Kitchenette - Fire Island
9.8Excellent 48 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$4300/nighttotal: HK$8600 (2 )

Fire Island Pines Modern Studio W/full Kitchenette

studio
Fire Island
About Fire Island Pines Modern Studio W/full Kitchenette

About: Apartment for up to 2 people with an excellent rating of 98% based on 48 reviews. This accommodation is located in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: a kitchen, a dish washer and a fridge. This apartment in Fire Island also has a garden!

Oceanfront Beach House In Ocean Beach Fire Island - Fire Island
9.2Excellent 15 reviews
Fire Island
2 4
HK$5660/nighttotal: HK$28300 (5 )

Oceanfront Beach House In Ocean Beach Fire Island

apartment
Fire Island
About Oceanfront Beach House In Ocean Beach Fire Island

About: Apartment to rent for up to 8 guests with an excellent rating of 92% based on 15 reviews. Your accommodation will be located in Fire Island.

Facilities and services include a washing machine and a kitchen.

Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit! - Fire Island
10Excellent 193 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$1975/nighttotal: HK$9875 (5 )

Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit!

apartment
Islip Terrace
About Beautifully Decorated1br Apartment - Full Kitchen, Private Backyard & Fire Pit!

About: Accommodation for 3 people with an excellent rating of 100% based on 193 reviews. You will be based in Islip Terrace.

Services and facilities: a barbecue, a spa and free parking. Take advantage of the air conditioning in this apartment!

One Bedroom Apartment With Private Deck - Fire Island
10Excellent 4 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$5171/nighttotal: HK$10342 (2 )

One Bedroom Apartment With Private Deck

apartment
Fire Island
About One Bedroom Apartment With Private Deck

About: Apartment to rent for up to 4 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 4 reviews. You will be based in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: a freeze, a terrace and a barbecue. Take advantage of the gym in this apartment.

Bellport Inn, Charming Cottage In The Village! - Fire Island
10Excellent 5 reviews
Fire Island
2 1
HK$10534/nighttotal: HK$52670 (5 )

Bellport Inn, Charming Cottage In The Village!

cottage
Bellport
About Bellport Inn, Charming Cottage In The Village!

About: Cottage for up to 6 people with an excellent rating of 100% based on 5 reviews. Your accommodation will be located in Bellport.

Facilities and services: free parking, a fridge and a jacuzzi. Take advantage of the garden in this accommodation in Bellport.